Brow gels can completely change the look of your makeup — they shape your expression, tie the whole face together, and keep everything looking polished.

I’ve gone through countless tubes at the drugstore, but two formulas always make their way back into my routine. After using (and repurchasing) both more times than I can count, here’s how they truly stack up!

1. e.l.f. Brow Lift

This formula has earned a permanent spot on my vanity. The texture hits that perfect middle ground — not too sticky, not too soft — and the hold is strong without feeling stiff. My favorite part? It keeps my brows lifted all day without a hint of flaking. It’s the gel I reach for on busy mornings because I know it will always deliver clean, sculpted brows with minimal effort.

2. NYX Brow Glue

Compact, convenient, and ideal for quick touch-ups, this brow gel is a solid runner-up in my routine. The built-in spoolie makes it easy to throw in a bag and use whenever my brows need a little refreshing. While it gives great hold initially, I’ve noticed that after a few hours, it can start to flake or lose its grip — something that keeps it from being my everyday choice. Still, for fast fixes, it definitely gets the job done.

Brows frame the face, so finding the right gel truly matters!