Lykkers, Brown lipstick has a way of making a makeup look feel instantly more polished without looking overly dramatic. I especially love shades that can work with simple makeup—just a little blush, curled lashes, and brown lips can already pull everything together.

Two brown lipsticks I keep in mind for different moods are Wet n Wild’s Cinnamon Spice and Bobbi Brown’s Crushed Lip Color in Satin Matte. One is an easy budget-friendly pick, while the other has that more refined, effortless finish I love.

1. Wet n Wild Mega Last Matte Lip Color — Cinnamon Spice

Price: $3.19

Cinnamon Spice is such a fun brown to have around because it does not feel boring or flat. The shade has that warm, spicy quality that makes it especially pretty with neutral makeup. I like the Mega Last formula when I want stronger color without spending much. The lipstick has a creamy feel when applied, then settles into a semi-matte finish. Wet n Wild describes it as full-coverage and long-lasting, with ingredients such as hyaluronic acid, vitamins A and E, and several nourishing oils.

2. Bobbi Brown Crushed Lip Color — Satin Matte

Price: $35

Bobbi Brown’s Crushed Lip Color has a completely different personality. The formula is designed to combine the appearance of lipstick with the comfortable feel of a balm, giving the lips a soft, blotted-down satin-matte effect. That finish is what makes it appealing to me. Instead of looking like a heavy layer of traditional matte lipstick, it has a more lived-in quality. One swipe can give a softer wash of color, while adding another layer builds the intensity.

These two give me completely different ways to wear brown lipstick. Cinnamon Spice is the affordable, warm, slightly more statement-making choice, while Bobbi Brown Crushed Lip Color leans softer, smoother, and more effortless. Sometimes I want that rich cinnamon-brown lip that immediately changes the whole makeup look. Other days, a blurred satin finish feels much more my style. A warmer shade can make a look cozy and bold, while a softer brown can feel almost like a natural lip color with extra definition. Which one would make it into your everyday makeup bag?