Greetings, Lykkers! A good eyeliner can completely change my makeup, even when I’m keeping everything else simple. I usually want something that gives me control, creates a clean line, and doesn’t make me spend forever fixing one tiny mistake.

These three liquid liners have different strengths, so I’d pick depending on the kind of eye look I’m going for.

1. essence Superfine Eyeliner Pen Waterproof — Around $5–$7

For an affordable everyday liner, the essence Superfine Eyeliner Pen Waterproof is an easy one to consider. The slim pen-style tip makes it useful when I want a thinner line instead of immediately going for a bold wing. I like this format for quick makeup days because I can build the line gradually. Starting close to the lash line and adding a little thickness at the outer corner gives me more control than trying to draw one perfect line in a single movement.

2. e.l.f. H2O Proof Inkwell Waterproof Eyeliner — Around $7–$10

When staying power matters more to me, e.l.f.’s H2O Proof Inkwell Waterproof Eyeliner gets my attention. The waterproof formula is made for a more secure eye look, which is especially nice when I don’t want to keep checking whether my liner has moved. The inkwell-style design also gives it a slightly different feel from a typical marker pen. I’d reach for this when I want a stronger black line or a sharper wing that stays part of the makeup rather than slowly disappearing throughout the day.

3. Mazu NYC Liquid Eyeliner Pen — Around $14–$15

Mazu NYC’s Liquid Eyeliner Pen feels like the choice I’d make when I want something a little more polished. What makes a liquid pen appealing to me is the precision. I can create a delicate line for an everyday look, then extend the outer corner when I want something more defined. It’s the kind of product I’d keep nearby when I’m experimenting with different wing shapes.

For a simple, budget-friendly option, I’d start with essence. e.l.f. makes more sense when waterproof wear is the priority, while Mazu NYC is worth considering when I want a more refined pen-style liner. Honestly, having different eyeliner options is never a bad idea—some days call for a tiny flick, and other days somehow turn into full wing territory.