Hi, Lykkers! Every eyeliner promises the perfect wing, but not every one actually delivers. I put these two to the test during busy days, quick makeup sessions, and even those moments when my eyeliner had to survive from morning coffee to dinner plans.

Here's how they ranked in my routine.

1. PINKFLASH Oh My Line Liquid Eyeliner — 5/5

If I could only keep one wing liner, this would probably be it. The brush feels like it knows exactly where I want the line to go, making sharp wings much easier than I expected. Even when my hands aren't cooperating, it still helps me fake a clean, lifted look. What really won me over is the staying power. Once it dries, I can stop thinking about it for the rest of the day. The black shade also looks beautifully bold, so my eyes instantly appear more defined without needing multiple layers. It's become the eyeliner I instinctively reach for whenever I don't want any surprises.

2. Madam Gie Wing It Lady Eyeliner — 4.5/5

This one deserves plenty of credit because creating a wing feels surprisingly comfortable. The tip gives me enough flexibility to play around with different styles, whether I'm going for something subtle or a dramatic cat eye. The finish stays looking neat for most of the day, and I like how lightweight it feels on my eyelids. The only reason it lands just behind my top pick is that I find myself making tiny touch-ups after long hours. Even so, it's still an eyeliner I'd happily wear again, especially when I want a polished look without spending too much time.

Choosing wasn't difficult in the end. PINKFLASH keeps impressing me with how effortless it makes winged eyeliner, while Madam Gie remains a solid option that rarely disappoints. Both have their strengths, but if someone asked which one I'd repurchase first, I'd point to PINKFLASH without hesitating.