Some beauty products earn cult status for a reason and even better when you can find a budget-friendly alternative that delivers a similar vibe.

Today’s comparison puts a luxury favorite against a drugstore gem to see how close you can get to that iconic look without the splurge. Let’s break it down, point by point.

1. Clinique Almost Lipstick – Black Honey

Clinique’s Almost Lipstick in Black Honey has been a classic for decades, and it continues to win hearts across generations. What makes Black Honey so beloved is its sheer, balm-like texture that lets your natural lip tone shine through. Rather than sitting heavily on the lips, it melts in smoothly and builds softly with each layer. The color itself is deceptively named—far from black, it reveals a deep berry tint with warm undertones that flatter a wide range of skin tones.

2. e.l.f. Hydrating Core Lip Shine – Ecstatic

On the more affordable end, e.l.f.’s Hydrating Core Lip Shine in Ecstatic steps up as a surprisingly strong contender. This product brings a similar sheer finish with a hint of shine, making it ideal for those who love a natural, comfortable lip look. The color payoff is light but noticeable, enhancing the lips rather than masking them. What sets this one apart is its hydrating core, which helps keep lips feeling smooth and nourished throughout the day.

Black Honey remains a timeless luxury staple, but Ecstatic proves you don’t need to spend much to achieve a similar effortless charm. Whether you choose high-end or drugstore, this comparison shows that great lip products come in all price ranges.