These two lip products are constantly compared, and for good reason.

Both formulas deliver comfort, shine, and long-lasting hydration, making them staples in my routine. I’ve used each one enough to notice their differences, and while they share similarities, they create very different lip looks. Here’s how they compare based on my experience.

1. Summer Fridays Lip Balm (Brown Sugar)

This balm feels rich and comforting the moment it touches the lips. The texture gives a smooth, cushion-like finish that lasts for hours. The scent is warm and inviting, making every application feel like a treat. The shade itself is beautiful, though it leans deeper than what I usually reach for. It’s perfect when you want lips to feel protected with a soft, balm-like appearance.

2. Rhode Skin Lip Treatment (Toast)

This one has become my everyday favorite. The formula melts onto the lips and delivers a high-shine finish that almost looks like a gloss. It pairs effortlessly with lip liner and complements my skin tone beautifully. The hydration level is impressive, and the shine makes the lips look fuller and smoother throughout the day.

Choosing between these two really depends on the finish you’re drawn to. Rhode gives a glossy, luminous look that feels fresh and modern, while Summer Fridays offers a thicker, more classic balm experience. Both are excellent in their own way, and neither disappoints. I’m curious—are you team shine or team balm?